Why large companies have outperformed in 2017

Since the start of the year, large cap stocks have outperformed small cap stocks in both the US and the Australian markets. In the US, this came as a big reversal for small companies, which reported huge gains immediately after the election of Donald Trump. Since the start of 2017, however, the Russell 2000, an index of small companies, has underperformed the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq by 4% and 8%, respectively.

Source: The Wall Street Journal

In Australia, the MSCI Australian Small Cap index has underperformed the ASX 200 by 3% this year. This is also a reversal relative to 2016, when small companies outperformed by about 5%.

2016 – Small Caps (black) vs Large Caps (green)

Source: barcharts

2017 – Small Caps (black) vs Large Caps (green)

Source: barcharts

So, what happened?

Part of the reason is just a correction of expectations, especially in the US. In November alone, US small caps surged by 11%, as investors expected that Trump’s tax changes and infrastructure plans would benefit smaller companies the most. Also, small caps, which tend to be less reliant on exports than larger companies, would be the least affected by potential trade wars and protectionism that could come from the new administration.

In Australia, large companies started to catch up in 2016, earlier than their US counterparts, but part of it was also due to a correction and a shift in sentiment.

The major reason, however, has to do with earnings growth. Domestically oriented companies are expected to grow slower than export oriented companies, as economic conditions improve around the world.

In Europe, Japan and China, business surveys and markets have turned more optimistic after signs that economic activity improved in the second half of last year. Oil prices increased after petroleum exporters reached an agreement to curb production, and trade protectionism seems to be on the retreat. This tends to benefit mostly larger companies.

In the US, S&P 500 companies more internationally exposed are expected to report twice the earnings growth of domestically focused companies.

Source: The Wall Street Journal

This is almost a complete reversal from one year ago, when a weak global economy was expected to hurt mostly earnings of international companies.

In Australia, the last earnings season also reinforced the small cap/large cap divide, as many previously admired small stocks announced disappointing results. Yowie Group, Genworth Mortgage Insurance and OFX group are good examples of smaller companies which missed either guidance or market consensus, and were heavily punished for it.

In the current conditions, and if most of the world continues to grow faster than domestic markets, we expect small cap weakness to persist.

If you want to learn how to invest in stocks and analyse the market to identify profitable or deadly turning points, contact United Global Capital today for a no cost, no obligation consultation on 03 8657 7640 or email [email protected] to learn about Quality, Value, Trend (QVT) investment selection methodology.

For a small yearly fee, learn how to take advantage of the current bull market and stay ahead of the crowd, with access to market news, updates and 20-30 stock recommendations per year in the Australian and US markets!

Previously an exclusive of UGC clients, UGC Research gives you access to the proven strategies used by UGC Securities to identify high return, low risk investment opportunities.

The information contained in this article is General in nature and has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation and needs.

Recent stories

Switching home loans

Refinancing your home loan to take advantage of a lower interest rate might save you money. Before you switch, make…

Read more

Tips to help make 2020/2021 tax time easier

It’s been a year of change like no other and that extends to tax and superannuation. As the end of…

Read more

The importance of having a will

While it’s not something anyone likes to think about, planning your estate may make things a little easier for your…

Read more

Fears and expectations

By Richard Dinham, Head of Client Solutions and Retirement For many, the word ‘retirement’ is associated with the idea of…

Read more

Savings accounts

Savings accounts help your money grow faster by offering a higher interest rate than everyday transaction accounts.  Get the highest…

Read more