Three key ingredients to improve your odds of outperformance

Listen to the episode

Is there a special recipe equity investors can follow to outperform the returns from the broader market?

Based on the latest performance scorecard of Australian active investment managers released in September by S&P Dow Jones Indices, if that recipe does exist, most professional portfolio managers don’t have it.

The SPIVA Australia Scorecard covering the year to 30 June, 2019 shows that, on an absolute return basis, out of around 850 Australian active equity funds, only a small percentage outperformed the indices they use to benchmark their performance.

While it’s probably cold comfort for most investors, the Australian results were not isolated. In fact, they were just a microcosm of similar underperformance trends recorded by active portfolio managers around the world.

Heightened global market volatility, fuelled by rising geopolitical tensions and weaker economic and business conditions, made last year particularly difficult for many active managers.

But what about the active fund managers who did outperform in the face of adversity? Were they doing something different to the majority by following a special recipe?

To answer that, one would need to look at the specific portfolios and strategies of each manager. However, what’s more important to recognise is that, while it’s interesting to measure short-term investment performances, active management is a long-term process.

An investment manager who outperforms over one year can just as easily underperform over the next, depending on a whole raft of factors.

Yet, there are three key ingredients investors should add to their investment recipe to improve the probability of achieving outperformance from actively managed funds over the longer term.

Ingredient 1: Identify top talent

Finding the best investment managers is critical to enhance one’s prospects of better returns, but where should one start in the context that past performance should never be used to gauge future returns?

Here at Vanguard, we believe a firm and its people must demonstrate a culture of investment excellence, strong experience and stewardship, have a clear philosophy and sound processes that can be executed well and consistently over time.

It’s also important that an active fund’s historical portfolio holdings and characteristics align with the manager’s overriding philosophy and processes, and that the drivers of past performance are logical and sustainable over the long term.

Ingredient 2: Keep costs low

The biggest quantitative ingredient that investors can control and use to improve the likelihood of outperformance is costs.

In effect, every dollar spent on investment-related costs including management fees is a dollar less in net return. So, it stands to reason that a lower-cost active manager will deliver better relative performance against a like competitor manager charging higher fees.

Of course, that’s not the complete story on costs. On an active management level, costs by themselves do not lead to consistently identifying active funds that will outperform.

Instead, low costs need to be identified and blended with investment talent to give one the best chance of achieving success through managed funds.

Ingredient 3: Patience is key

As noted above, challenging market conditions can have a harmful impact on the performance of investment managers, irrespective of their past track record.

In fact, even the top-performing investment managers over longer periods are likely to underperform their benchmark at some stage due to unforeseen events.

While low costs and a rigorous, considered manager selection process can go a long way to improve your results using active management, those benefits can be eroded significantly if one fails to maintain a long-term perspective.

This is because there is inconsistency inherent in achieving excess returns. Returns will invariably differ from year to year.

Understanding this inconsistency is critical for those who may be tempted to use short-term past performance as a primary basis for entering and exiting active funds.


Successful active management needs to be driven by a combination of top talent, low costs, and patience.

While outperforming the broader market is the ongoing objective for all active fund managers, achieving outperformance consistently is full of challenges.

Vanguard has close to $2 trillion in active assets under management globally and, spanning back to our beginnings in 1975, our extensive research confirms that active funds that have shown better performance returns over time are those run by experienced and talented managers, have low cost structures, and take a patient rather than reactive investment approach.

Depending on one’s investment strategy and risk tolerance, actively managed funds remain a good complement and diversifier to other types of products such as index-tracking managed funds and exchange-traded funds.

Source : Vanguard October 2019 

Reproduced with permission of Vanguard Investments Australia Ltd

Vanguard Investments Australia Ltd (ABN 72 072 881 086 / AFS Licence 227263) is the product issuer. We have not taken yours and your clients’ circumstances into account when preparing this material so it may not be applicable to the particular situation you are considering. You should consider your circumstances and our Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) or Prospectus before making any investment decision. You can access our PDS or Prospectus online or by calling us. This material was prepared in good faith and we accept no liability for any errors or omissions. Past performance is not an indication of future performance.

© 2019 Vanguard Investments Australia Ltd. All rights reserved.

Any information provided by the author detailed above is separate and external to our business and our Licensee. Neither our business nor our Licensee takes any responsibility for any action or any service provided by the author.

Any links have been provided with permission for information purposes only and will take you to external websites, which are not connected to our company in any way. Note: Our company does not endorse and is not responsible for the accuracy of the contents/information contained within the linked site(s) accessible from this page.

Recent stories

Understanding the Sharemarket: A Beginner’s Guide

Listen to the episodeInvesting in the sharemarket can be a powerful way to grow your wealth over time. Whether you’re…

Read more

Franked Dividends vs Unfranked Dividends

Listen to the episodeWhen it comes to investing in the stock market, understanding the nuances of dividend payments is crucial.…

Read more

UGC Monthly Market Update | May 2024

Listen to the episodeJoin UGC’s Head of Research / Co-Portfolio Manager, Huw Davies, as he takes a deep dive into…

Read more

If aged care advice is confusing – get advice

Listen to the episodeMany people think they can’t afford to get aged care advice, but the reality is you probably…

Read more

Mastering the Tax Game: Boost Your Wealth & Trim Your Tax

Listen to the episodeAs the end of the financial year approaches, it’s the perfect time to refine your tax strategies…

Read more